Ashley Klein Dropped After Controversial Warriors vs Knights Finish

Klein has come under criticism again after some controversial calls

21 Sept 2026·5 min read·by Taj Soupidis

Photo: Getty Images

Ashley Klein has been dropped from this weekend's NRL preliminary finals after the league admitted he made a crucial error during Newcastle's controversial 12-10 victory over the New Zealand Warriors at Eden Park.

The decision comes after a dramatic finish in Auckland, where three major refereeing calls in the final stages of the semi-final sparked widespread debate.

The NRL's review has determined that one of those three decisions was incorrect and it came with less than a minute remaining.

The decision that changed everything

With the Warriors trailing 12-10 and desperately searching for an opportunity to level the match, Te Maire Martin put up a high kick towards the Newcastle defensive line.

Warriors centre Leka Halasima chased the ball as Knights forward Tyson Frizell moved across his path.

Frizell appeared to impede Halasima as the Warriors player attempted to chase the kick, with the Warriors immediately appealing for an escort penalty.

Klein ruled that there was no infringement and allowed play to continue. The decision proved hugely significant.

The NRL's subsequent review determined that Frizell should have been penalised for the escort.

Had the penalty been awarded, the Warriors would have had an opportunity to kick a penalty goal from in front of the posts and tie the game at 12-12.

That would have sent the match into golden point. Instead, Newcastle survived the final moments and secured a famous 12-10 victory.

Why couldn't the bunker intervene?

One of the biggest questions surrounding the incident is why the bunker was unable to overturn the decision.

The bunker cannot simply intervene whenever an on-field official misses an infringement. Its powers are restricted to specific incidents and reviewable decisions.

The Frizell incident was a non-call on the field, meaning the bunker could not simply step in and award the Warriors a penalty.

The Warriors had also already used their captain's challenge. As a result, the decision ultimately remained with Klein and his on-field team.

The NRL has since acknowledged that the call was incorrect.

Three controversial decisions in the final stages

The Frizell incident wasn't the only controversial decision during the final stages of the match.

There were three major calls that became the focus of debate.

Ali Leiataua's fingertip

With around eight minutes remaining, Knights captain Kalyn Ponga created an opportunity for Bradman Best, who appeared to lose the ball forward.

Klein initially ruled that Newcastle had knocked the ball on.

Ponga challenged the decision, arguing that Warriors centre Ali Leiataua had touched the ball.

The bunker conducted an extensive review and determined that Leiataua had made contact with the ball.

The original decision was overturned and Newcastle retained possession.

The Warriors questioned the length of the review and the decision, but the NRL's subsequent review backed the bunker.

Te Maire Martin's alleged strip

Only minutes later, another contentious decision went against the Warriors.

Knights winger Greg Marzhew carried the ball into the Warriors defensive line before being tackled by Mitch Barnett and Te Maire Martin.

As the tackle finished, the ball came loose. Klein immediately ruled that Martin had stripped the ball and awarded Newcastle a penalty.

The Warriors challenged the decision, arguing that Marzhew had simply lost possession during the tackle.

The bunker upheld Klein's decision.

The call remains one of the more heavily debated moments from the match, but the NRL review ultimately supported the original ruling.

Tyson Frizell's escort

Then came the decision that has ultimately cost Klein his place in the preliminary finals.

With less than a minute remaining, Halasima chased Martin's high kick while Frizell moved across the Warriors player's path.

Klein did not award a penalty. The NRL's review later determined that he should have.

It was the only one of the three major late-game decisions that the league ruled to have been incorrect.

Given the scoreline, the mistake could have directly changed the outcome of the match.

The Warriors demand answers

The Warriors have since sought an explanation from the NRL over the controversial officiating decisions.

Warriors chief executive Cameron George contacted the league and requested clarification about the calls. The club has made it clear that it does not expect the result to be changed.

Instead, the Warriors want to understand how the decisions were reached and ensure there is accountability around the officiating process.

Coach Andrew Webster was also visibly frustrated following the match.

The Warriors had fought their way into the finals before being eliminated by Newcastle in front of a record crowd at Eden Park.

Klein dropped from preliminary finals

Klein has now been left out of the referee appointments for this weekend's preliminary finals.

The experienced referee had officiated all three matches in the 2026 State of Origin series and had been one of the NRL's most prominent officials.

However, following the review of the Warriors-Knights match, he will not take charge of either preliminary final.

The decision could also affect his chances of refereeing the 2026 NRL Grand Final.

The NRL's remaining senior referees will now be considered for the two preliminary finals and the season decider.

Ugly scenes after full-time

The controversy took an even uglier turn after the final whistle.

As Klein and the other match officials attempted to leave the field, spectators threw bottles, cups and other objects towards them.

Security personnel were required to assist the officials as they made their way from the playing surface.

The NRL has launched an investigation through its Integrity Unit into the behaviour of the spectators involved.

The league has warned that supporters identified as having thrown objects could face bans from attending NRL matches.

Police were also present at Eden Park, with two people reported to have entered the field.

The match attracted a record crowd of 48,511 spectators, making the scenes after full-time particularly concerning for the league.

The Knights keep their season alive

Despite the controversy, Newcastle's victory cannot simply be attributed to the final refereeing decision.

The Knights produced a superb defensive effort to hold out the Warriors and secure a two-point victory.

Their turnaround has been remarkable.

After finishing last in the NRL in 2025, Newcastle are now just one victory away from reaching the 2026 Grand Final.

They will face the Penrith Panthers in Sunday's preliminary final at Accor Stadium.

Kalyn Ponga also confirmed that he passed his head injury assessment after being taken from the field late in the match and is expected to be available for Newcastle's biggest game of the season.

The Knights are now chasing their first Grand Final appearance since 2001.

Comments (0)

Sign in to comment, like or dislike.

Loading…

Explore Football Central