Start, Bench, Sell: Manchester United (Pochettino Edition)
With Mauricio Pochettino poised to take over at Old Trafford, it's time to decide who should be part of Manchester United's rebuild, who deserves a place on the bench and who should be shown the door

Photo: Getty Images
Manchester United are back at another crossroads. Michael Carrick has been dismissed following a disastrous start to the season, with United sitting in the Premier League relegation zone after winning just once in their opening 10 league matches.
Mauricio Pochettino is now expected to take charge, bringing with him the challenge of restoring belief, identity and consistency at Old Trafford.
But a new manager cannot fix everything simply by changing the name on the dugout.
United need to make some difficult decisions about the squad, particularly with the January transfer window approaching.
There are players who should be central to the project, others who can still offer something valuable, and a number who may have reached the end of their time at the club.
So, in the first edition of START, BENCH, SELL going into the January transfer window, here's how I'd divide the Manchester United squad ahead of the Pochettino era.

START — BUILD THE TEAM AROUND THEM
Bruno Fernandes
There should be very little debate about Bruno. He's the captain, the creative heartbeat of the side and one of the few players who consistently takes responsibility when things are going wrong.
Pochettino needs leaders, personality and players capable of making things happen in the final third. Bruno provides all three. Even if the new manager changes the system, he should remain one of the first names on the teamsheet.
Bryan Mbeumo
One of the most important attacking players in this squad. Mbeumo offers pace, directness, goals and the ability to operate across the forward line.
United have lacked consistent attacking threat for far too long. Mbeumo should be given the responsibility to become a major part of the solution rather than another player caught up in the club's constant changes.
Kobbie Mainoo
A young midfielder with the ability to become a long-term cornerstone of the team. Mainoo brings composure in possession and the ability to progress the ball through midfield.
United have spent years searching for a midfield identity. Giving Mainoo a consistent role should be part of the rebuild.
Matheus Cunha
Alongside Bryan Mbeumo, Cunha is of the most important attacking players in this squad. Cunha offeres the same skills, offers pace, directness, goals and the ability to operate across the forward line.
With the likes of Mbeumo, Fernandes, and Cunha in the attack, this is a strong basis to build the team around.
BENCH — USEFUL, BUT NOT UNTOUCHABLE
Harry Maguire
Maguire has experienced plenty of criticism during his United career, but his physical presence and aerial ability still make him a useful option.
He shouldn't automatically be considered a starter, particularly if Pochettino wants a defence capable of playing a high line. However, having an experienced centre-back available is valuable over a long season.
Joshua Zirkzee
There is a player in Zirkzee, particularly when it comes to linking play and bringing others into attacks. But United need more consistent output from their forwards.
He should be kept as an option, although the club must decide whether he is capable of becoming a reliable first-choice striker.
The same applies to several of the younger players in the squad. They should be given opportunities, but there is no need to rush their development.
Carlos Baleba
Baleba is an interesting one. His physical presence, energy and ability to win the ball make him an exciting midfield option, but there is still room for development in his game.
He has the attributes to become an important player in a Pochettino side, particularly if United want a more aggressive and athletic midfield. However, the expectation should not be that he immediately becomes the answer to every problem in the middle of the pitch.
Keeping him in the squad and allowing him to develop without placing too much pressure on his shoulders could be the smartest approach.
Leny Yoro
There is no question about Yoro's potential. At his age, he already possesses many of the qualities required to become a top-level centre-back.
However, Manchester United need to be careful not to rush his development. A young defender needs consistency, experience and the right environment around him.
Pochettino has a history of developing young talent, and Yoro could benefit enormously from working under him. He should remain an important part of the project, but United need to manage his minutes and expectations properly.
Patrick Dorgu
Dorgu offers something different. His athleticism, versatility and ability to contribute going forward make him an interesting option, particularly in a system that demands energy from its wide players and full-backs.
There is plenty to like, but he still needs to develop his consistency and decision-making.
Rather than immediately making him an automatic starter, keeping Dorgu as an important squad option gives Pochettino flexibility while allowing the youngster to continue improving.
SELL — TIME TO MOVE ON?
Marcus Rashford
This is arguably the biggest decision on the list.
Rashford has produced some outstanding moments in a United shirt, but the club needs to look forward rather than keep relying on what he has done in the past.
If Pochettino doesn't see him as a central part of his plans, January could be an opportunity to find a solution. United need consistency, commitment and reliable performances from their attacking players.
A fresh start could benefit both parties.
Diogo Dalot
Dalot has been a regular presence at Manchester United, but the question is whether he is good enough to be part of a team seriously challenging for major honours.
He offers versatility and can contribute going forward, but there are still concerns about his defensive consistency and decision-making.
If Pochettino wants to build a more reliable defensive unit, United may need to look at upgrading the full-back positions. Dalot could attract interest and potentially provide funds for a replacement.
Luke Shaw
Shaw's ability has never really been the biggest question. When fit, he has shown he can be an excellent left-back and a valuable option in possession.
The issue is availability. Manchester United cannot continue relying on a player whose fitness has regularly been a concern. If Pochettino wants to establish a consistent starting XI, he needs players he can trust to be available week after week.
It may be time for United to consider a new long-term solution at left-back. He seems part of the old guard, it's time to move on.
Lisandro Martínez
This is arguably one of the more controversial decisions.
Martínez brings aggression, leadership and excellent ability on the ball. His personality and commitment have made him popular with supporters, and there is no denying his quality when available.
However, questions remain over his criticism of the club, his red card, and his attitude towards the club.
Manuel Ugarte
Ugarte's situation is particularly interesting because United have been crying out for a reliable defensive midfielder.
He brings aggression, tackling ability and energy, but there are questions about his ability to control games in possession and contribute to a midfield capable of dominating the opposition.
Pochettino will need midfielders who can win the ball but also use it effectively. If Ugarte cannot offer enough in possession, United may decide that a different profile is needed.
The club cannot afford to keep signing midfielders who only solve half the problem.
THE BIGGER PICTURE: POCHETTINO NEEDS BACKING
The most important thing for Manchester United is that this does not become another rebuild that lasts only until the next manager arrives.
Pochettino needs to establish a clear identity, make difficult decisions and receive proper backing in the transfer market. The January window will provide an early opportunity to address the squad's biggest weaknesses, but United must avoid signing players simply because they are available.
The club needs a reliable defensive structure, greater balance in midfield and more consistent production in attack.
There are talented players already at Old Trafford. The challenge is building a team that actually works together.
But that's just my opinion…
Who would you START, BENCH or SELL at Manchester United?
Comments (0)
Sign in to comment, like or dislike.
Loading…
