Klopp vs Arteta: The Premier League Debate Dividing Fans

Who is actually the better manager: Jürgen Klopp or Mikel Arteta?

9 Nov 2026·6 min read·by Taj Soupidis
Photo: Getty Images

With Arsenal now having won the Premier League under Mikel Arteta and in a solid early position to win another, the debate between Liverpool and Arsenal supporters has taken another twist. Who is actually the better manager: Jürgen Klopp or Mikel Arteta?

Liverpool supporters argue that Klopp achieved more in a tougher era, competing against Pep Guardiola's Manchester City and pushing the standards of English football to extraordinary levels.

Arsenal supporters meanwhile, point towards Arteta's recent dominance over Klopp in the league table, his transformation of Arsenal and the suggestion that he has now surpassed the German.

But when the statistics are examined, there is more to this debate than simply counting trophies.


Klopp's extraordinary Liverpool era


Jürgen Klopp arrived at Liverpool in October 2015, inheriting a side that had finished sixth in the Premier League the previous season. What followed was one of the most successful managerial periods in the club's history.

He transformed Liverpool into a European powerhouse, winning the Champions League in 2019 before ending the club's 30-year wait for a league championship in 2020.

His Premier League record was equally impressive. Across 334 matches, Klopp recorded 209 victories, 78 draws and 47 defeats, collecting 705 points at an average of 2.11 points per game.

However, one of the strongest arguments in Klopp's favour is the quality of competition he faced.

Liverpool accumulated 97 points in the 2018/19 season and still finished second, one point behind Manchester City. Three years later, they collected another 92 points but again finished runners-up, this time one point behind Guardiola's side.

Those campaigns demonstrate just how extraordinary the competition from Manchester City was. Liverpool could produce seasons that would have comfortably won the Premier League in many other eras and still walk away without the trophy.

Klopp eventually departed Liverpool with seven major trophies, including a Premier League title, Champions League, FA Cup and two League Cups.


Arteta's transformation of Arsenal


Mikel Arteta's journey has been considerably different.

When he arrived at Arsenal in December 2019, the club was struggling to compete consistently for Champions League qualification.

His first two full Premier League seasons ended with eighth-place finishes, and questions were being asked about whether he was the right man to lead the rebuild.

However, the progression that followed was remarkable. Arsenal finished fifth in 2021/22 before mounting a serious title challenge in 2022/23. They collected 84 points but ultimately finished second behind Manchester City.

The following season, Arsenal improved again, collecting 89 points. Despite winning 28 matches, they once again finished runners-up, this time two points behind City.

After another second-place finish in 2024/25, Arteta finally delivered the Premier League title in 2025/26.

His Arsenal project had gone from eighth in the league to champions, demonstrating the scale of the transformation.

This is where Arsenal supporters have their strongest argument against Klopp.

In both 2022/23 and 2023/24, Arteta's Arsenal finished above Klopp's Liverpool. Arsenal collected 84 points compared to Liverpool's 67 in the first season, followed by 89 compared to Liverpool's 82 in the second.

For Arsenal supporters, these seasons demonstrate that Arteta had built a team capable of outperforming Klopp's Liverpool in direct competition.

However, Liverpool's response is that two seasons should not outweigh an entire managerial legacy.


Was Klopp's competition harder?


This is arguably the most important part of the entire debate. Liverpool supporters frequently point towards Manchester City's dominance during Klopp's reign.

Guardiola's side were setting extraordinary standards, regularly collecting more than 90 points and leaving very little room for mistakes.

Liverpool's 97-point season in 2018/19 remains one of the highest points totals in Premier League history for a team that failed to win the title.

But Arsenal supporters can argue that Arteta has faced the same challenge.

Guardiola's Manchester City remained the dominant force throughout much of Arteta's Arsenal reign. In fact, Arsenal finished second behind City three consecutive times before finally winning the championship in 2025/26.

There is also a difference in the way the two teams eventually achieved success.

Klopp's Liverpool needed 99 points to win the league in 2019/20, while Arteta's Arsenal finally got over the line with 85 points in 2025/26.

That does not diminish Arsenal's achievement. Winning a Premier League title requires consistency, quality and handling pressure across an entire season, regardless of the final points total.

However, it does show why Liverpool supporters believe Klopp's title-winning achievement deserves particular recognition.


The Arne Slot argument


Another interesting part of the debate is Arne Slot's immediate success following Klopp's departure.

Slot inherited a Liverpool squad that had finished third in 2023/24 and managed to win the Premier League in his first season.

Liverpool finished the 2024/25 campaign with 84 points, 25 victories and 86 goals scored, securing the championship four matches before the end of the season.

Some Liverpool supporters use this as evidence that Klopp had left behind an excellent squad and that Slot was able to get the best out of a group of players already capable of winning the league.

There is certainly an argument there. However, it would be unfair to use Slot's success to undermine Klopp. The German was responsible for building much of the squad, establishing the club's culture and returning Liverpool to the top of European football.

Equally, Slot deserves enormous credit for making the necessary tactical adjustments and delivering the title.

Arsenal supporters can also point out that Arteta had to undertake a much longer rebuilding process before reaching the same destination. The two situations are not directly comparable.


Did Arteta force Klopp into retirement?


One of the more entertaining claims coming from Arsenal supporters is that Arteta effectively forced Klopp into retirement.

There is some ammunition for the banter. Arsenal finished above Liverpool in Klopp's final two full Premier League seasons, and Arteta had established his side as genuine title contenders.

However, the reality is considerably different. Klopp announced his departure in January 2024, explaining that he was running out of energy after an incredibly demanding period in management. He had informed Liverpool's ownership of his decision months earlier.

Klopp's final season actually ended with a League Cup trophy and a third-place Premier League finish.

The suggestion that Arteta sent Klopp into retirement might make for good rivalry banter, but it does not stand up as a factual explanation. Arteta putting Arsenal into the title equation certainly would've contributed to Klopp's burnout, but wasn't the sole factor.


The statistics: Who comes out ahead?


Comparing their Premier League records highlights the differences between their careers.

Jürgen Klopp

Premier League games: 334
Record: 209/78/47
Points: 705, 2.11 per game
EPL Titles: 1

Mikel Arteta

Premier League games: 248*
Record: 149/48/51*
Points: 495. 2.00 per game*
EPL Titles: 1*


Klopp currently leads on overall points per game, while both managers have delivered a Premier League championship.

Klopp also has the advantage in European honours and overall trophy collection. Arteta, however, has demonstrated an impressive ability to rebuild Arsenal and has now delivered the league title after several seasons of near misses, matching Klopp's total haul already.


So, who is the better manager?


The argument ultimately comes down to what supporters value most. If the discussion is about overall managerial achievements, Klopp has an incredibly strong case.

His Champions League triumph, Premier League success, consistency and ability to challenge Manchester City make his Liverpool tenure one of the great managerial spells in modern English football.

But Arteta's achievements should not be dismissed simply because Klopp has a bigger trophy collection.

Taking Arsenal from eighth place to Premier League champions is a significant accomplishment.

Finishing above Klopp's Liverpool in consecutive seasons also provides genuine statistical evidence that Arteta had built a side capable of outperforming one of the strongest Liverpool teams in the club's history.

The Slot argument is interesting, but it does not prove Klopp was replaceable. Similarly, Arsenal finishing above Liverpool does not mean Arteta forced Klopp out of management.

For now, Klopp's overall managerial legacy remains backed by a greater collection of achievements.

Arteta, however, has reached the Premier League summit and has the opportunity to build a legacy of his own that surpasses Klopp, and if he can deliver that first piece of European silverware and more Premier League title, that would put his name firmly ahead in this conversation.

Perhaps the most uncomfortable reality for both fanbases is that the two managers can be celebrated without one having to be diminished.

Klopp built Liverpool into champions. Arteta has now done the same with Arsenal.

With Arsenal finally getting over the line, the debate is only going to become louder.

Comments (0)

Sign in to comment, like or dislike.

Loading…

Explore Football Central