Manchester City Could Face Another Premier League Investigation as Fresh Financial Questions Emerge
There are growing calls for the Premier League to investigate the club's commercial arrangements beyond 2018

Photo: Getty Images
Manchester City's financial controversy could be about to enter another chapter, with growing calls for the Premier League to investigate the club's commercial arrangements beyond 2018.
According to a report by The Independent's chief football writer Miguel Delaney, an increasing number of football executives believe the Premier League should examine whether the financial arrangements scrutinised during its original investigation continued after the 2017-18 season.
The renewed scrutiny comes after an independent commission found City guilty of 114 charges relating to serious breaches of Premier League financial regulations. However, the latest reports do not mean a second investigation has officially been launched, and City are continuing to challenge the original findings.
With questions now being raised about the years that followed the period covered by the original case, the situation could become even more complicated for the reigning English football powerhouse.
Why are Manchester City facing calls for another investigation?
The latest debate centres on a question being raised by rival club executives: if the commercial arrangements identified in the original case were allegedly used to disguise funding before 2018, did those arrangements genuinely stop afterwards?
The original investigation examined Manchester City's financial reporting between the 2009-10 and 2017-18 seasons.
According to the independent commission's findings, City used commercial agreements with a number of Abu Dhabi-based sponsors that did not accurately reflect who was funding the payments.
The commission found that the arrangements were part of a disguised funding scheme involving companies connected to the club's ownership.
The latest concerns relate to the fact that City's commercial income reportedly remained at a similar level after 2018.
Some rival executives are questioning what changed at that point and whether the Premier League should examine the subsequent seasons in greater detail.
The argument is that, if the relationships between the club and its associated sponsors remained the same, further questions could arise about whether sponsorship arrangements were properly assessed and reported.
However, that is an argument for further scrutiny, not proof that Manchester City committed additional breaches after 2018.
What happened in the original 115-charge case?
The Premier League's original investigation began in December 2018, with formal charges issued in February 2023.
The case covered nine seasons, from 2009-10 through to 2017-18, and included allegations concerning inaccurate financial information, sponsorship revenue, payments and the club's cooperation with the investigation.
On September 29, 2026, the Premier League announced that an independent commission had found Manchester City guilty of 114 charges.
Among the commission's findings were that the club had used sham commercial agreements to artificially inflate revenue and reduce reported costs, while also submitting misstated accounts.
The Premier League's published summary said the arrangements had artificially inflated revenue and reduced costs by more than £900 million during the period examined.
The commission also upheld three of the four alleged breaches relating to City's cooperation with the Premier League investigation.
The findings represented a major development in one of English football's longest-running financial disputes.
However, City have consistently denied wrongdoing and have challenged the commission's decision.
Manchester City formally appealed the decision on October 2, with the Premier League confirming that the case had been referred to the independent Appeal Board.
The appeal proceedings are being conducted privately, meaning supporters are unlikely to receive immediate clarity on the arguments being presented or when a final outcome will be announced.
The appeal is particularly important because the outcome of the original case could influence how the Premier League approaches any potential investigation into later seasons.
If the original findings are overturned or significantly changed, the debate surrounding a second investigation could look very different. If they are upheld, pressure for further scrutiny may increase.
Why is another investigation considered a dilemma?
While some executives reportedly want the Premier League to investigate the period after 2018, there is also concern about the consequences of opening another lengthy legal battle.
The original case took years to reach a commission decision, with the hearing itself lasting 42 days and concluding in December 2024.
There are concerns that another investigation could take several more years, creating further uncertainty for the Premier League, its clubs and supporters.
There is also the question of evidence. The original investigation was built partly around leaked emails published by Der Spiegel in 2018, which helped bring the alleged financial arrangements into the spotlight.
Without comparable evidence covering the years after 2018, establishing a basis for another case could prove more difficult.
Some executives believe the Premier League should concentrate on completing the existing proceedings and determining appropriate sanctions before considering another investigation.
Others reportedly believe the possibility of further scrutiny could become a negotiating tool when discussions around sanctions and the club's future take place.
That does not mean a deal has been agreed or that the Premier League has decided against investigating further. It highlights the competing pressures surrounding the situation.
Could Manchester City face more punishment?
For now, the immediate disciplinary question concerns the original 114 charges.
The Premier League has confirmed that sanctions will be determined separately from the commission's findings. Its rules allow for a range of punishments, including fines, points deductions and other sporting sanctions.
There has also been speculation about possible title-related consequences, although no decision to strip Manchester City of any trophies has been announced.
The possibility of a separate investigation into post-2018 seasons would introduce another layer of uncertainty.
Any additional charges would need to be properly investigated and established through the Premier League's disciplinary process. They cannot simply be assumed because the original commission reached its findings about an earlier period.
For City, the immediate priority remains their appeal and the eventual outcome of the existing case.
So what happens next?
The next major developments are likely to come from the appeal process and the separate proceedings to determine sanctions.
The Premier League has not publicly confirmed that it is opening a fresh investigation into Manchester City's finances after 2018.
Nevertheless, the fact that rival club executives are reportedly pushing for further scrutiny shows that the controversy is far from disappearing.
The period following 2018 includes some of the most successful years in Manchester City's history. Under Pep Guardiola, the club won multiple Premier League titles, achieved a historic domestic treble and lifted the Champions League for the first time.
That success is now part of the wider debate about whether the Premier League should examine the club's finances beyond the seasons covered by the original case.
For now, Manchester City remain focused on appealing the existing findings, while the Premier League faces growing questions about whether its investigation should end with the original nine-season period.
One thing is clear. The Manchester City financial saga is not going away.
Whether the latest calls lead to a second investigation remains to be seen, but the questions surrounding the club's post-2018 finances have now become another major talking point in English football.
Comments (0)
Sign in to comment, like or dislike.
Loading…
