16 Games and Gone: Where Pierre Sage's Crystal Palace Exit Ranks Among the Premier League's Shortest Managerial Reigns

There is perhaps no more unforgiving job in football than managing a Premier League club

13 Nov 2026·9 min read·by Taj Soupidis

Photo: Getty Images


From Frank de Boer's four-game disaster at Crystal Palace to Ange Postecoglou's 39-day Nottingham Forest nightmare, Premier League history is full of managers who barely got started before being shown the door.

Now Pierre Sage has joined that list, while Michael Carrick's Manchester United departure provides another reminder of how quickly fortunes can change.

There is perhaps no more unforgiving job in football than managing a Premier League club.

One minute, a manager is being welcomed with promises of a long-term project. A few poor results later, those promises can disappear, contracts become meaningless and the search for a replacement begins.

Crystal Palace's decision to dismiss Pierre Sage after just 16 matches is the latest example.

The Frenchman arrived at Selhurst Park in June on a three-year contract, replacing Oliver Glasner. However, after only five months, Palace have decided to change direction, with the club sitting bottom of the Premier League.

Sage leaves having won just two of his 10 league matches, drawing one and losing seven. Palace's four consecutive league defeats, including a 3-1 home loss to Liverpool, proved the final straw.

But where does his departure rank among the shortest managerial spells in Premier League history, and who else has been given barely any time to make their mark?


THE SHORTEST PREMIER LEAGUE MANAGERIAL SPELLS


Records below refer to league matches in the relevant spell, not necessarily every competition.

Frank de Boer – Crystal Palace

Frank de Boer – Crystal Palace

Photo: Getty Images


4 Premier League matches | 0 wins, 0 draws, 4 defeats

Frank de Boer's time at Crystal Palace remains one of the most infamous managerial disasters in Premier League history.

The Dutchman arrived in June 2017 with a reputation built on his successful period at Ajax, where he won four consecutive Eredivisie titles.

Palace wanted to move towards a more possession-based style of football, but the transition was disastrous.

The Eagles lost their opening four Premier League matches without scoring a single goal. Their defeats came against Huddersfield, Liverpool, Swansea and Burnley.

His only victory came in the League Cup against Ipswich Town. After just 77 days and four league matches, Palace pulled the trigger, replacing him with Roy Hodgson.

De Boer remains the only permanent Premier League manager to leave a club after four league matches without collecting a single point.


Sam Allardyce – Leeds United

Sam Allardyce – Leeds United

Photo: Getty Images


4 Premier League matches | 0 wins, 1 draw, 3 defeats

Allardyce's Leeds appointment was an emergency operation.

With four matches remaining in the 2022-23 season, Leeds turned to the experienced manager in an attempt to avoid relegation.

He inherited a side sitting just above the relegation zone on goal difference and was tasked with keeping them in the Premier League.

The results were disappointing. A 2-1 defeat to Manchester City was followed by a 2-2 draw against Newcastle, before further defeats to West Ham and Tottenham.

Leeds collected just one point from a possible 12 and were relegated.

Allardyce's contract expired at the end of the season, meaning he was not technically sacked. His 30-day spell remains the shortest managerial reign by days in Premier League history.


Ange Postecoglou – Nottingham Forest

Ange Postecoglou – Nottingham Forest

Photo: Getty Images


5 Premier League matches | 0 wins, 1 draw, 4 defeats

Postecoglou's Nottingham Forest appointment was a gamble from the beginning.

He replaced Nuno Espírito Santo in September 2025, despite the two managers having very different footballing philosophies.

Nuno had established a more direct and pragmatic approach, while Postecoglou wanted to implement his attacking, possession-based football.

The transition never got going. Forest failed to win any of Postecoglou's first eight matches in all competitions, collecting just one point from five Premier League games.

His final match was a 3-0 home defeat to Chelsea. The Australian was dismissed just minutes after the final whistle, ending his reign after only 39 days.

It remains the shortest mid-season permanent managerial reign in Premier League history.


Les Reed – Charlton Athletic

Les Reed – Charlton Athletic

Photo: Getty Images


7 Premier League matches | 1 win, 1 draw, 5 defeats

Les Reed's appointment at Charlton in November 2006 was an unexpected one.

Having previously worked as Alan Curbishley's assistant, Reed was promoted following the dismissal of Iain Dowie.

However, his first experience as a professional club manager quickly became a nightmare.

Charlton managed just four points from seven league matches, while an embarrassing League Cup defeat to fourth-tier Wycombe Wanderers added to the pressure.

Reed was dismissed after only 40 days. His departure did little to save Charlton, who were relegated at the end of the season.


Nathan Jones – Southampton

Nathan Jones – Southampton

Photo: Getty Images


8 Premier League matches | 1 win, 0 draws, 7 defeats

Jones arrived at Southampton in November 2022 after impressing at Luton Town.

The appointment was supposed to bring organisation and energy to a struggling side, but his Premier League spell became one of the most difficult managerial reigns in recent memory.

Southampton lost seven of his eight league matches, with their only victory coming against Everton.

His relationship with supporters deteriorated, performances failed to improve and his comments following defeats attracted further criticism.

A 2-1 defeat to ten-man Wolves proved to be his final match. Jones was dismissed after 94 days, with Southampton rooted to the bottom of the table.


Quique Sánchez Flores – Watford

Quique Sánchez Flores – Watford

Photo: Getty Images


10 Premier League matches | 2 wins, 1 draw, 7 defeats

Flores' second spell at Watford lasted just 85 days. Pretty good for Watford considering their patience with managers....

The Spaniard had previously enjoyed a successful first spell at Vicarage Road, guiding Watford to a comfortable mid-table finish and an FA Cup semi-final in 2016.

However, his return in September 2019 was very different. Watford struggled badly, winning just two of their first 10 league matches under him.

The club's decision to dismiss Flores came as part of another attempt to turn around their season, with Nigel Pearson eventually appointed.

Watford ultimately managed to escape relegation, finishing 19th but surviving on the final day.


Bob Bradley – Swansea City

Bob Bradley – Swansea City

Photo: Getty Images


11 Premier League matches | 2 wins, 2 draws, 7 defeats

Bradley made history when he became the first American manager in Premier League history, taking charge of Swansea City in October 2016.

He replaced Francesco Guidolin, who had been dismissed following a disappointing start to the season.

However, Bradley struggled to turn things around. Swansea won just two of his 11 league matches, collecting eight points and conceding heavily.

A 4-1 defeat to West Ham was his final match, with the club sitting 17th and just one point above the relegation zone.

He was dismissed after 84 days.


Javi Gracia – Leeds United

Javi Gracia – Leeds United

Photo: Getty Images


11 Premier League matches | 3 wins, 2 draws, 6 defeats

Gracia was brought in to replace Jesse Marsch in February 2023, with Leeds fighting to avoid relegation.

His appointment initially appeared to be working. Leeds picked up important victories, including a 4-2 win over Wolves and a 4-2 victory against Nottingham Forest.

However, the club's form deteriorated towards the end of his spell. A 5-1 home defeat to Crystal Palace and a 6-1 defeat to Liverpool exposed serious defensive problems.

Gracia was dismissed in May, with Leeds sitting just outside the relegation zone.

His replacement, Sam Allardyce, was unable to save the club. Interestingly, Leeds were actually outside the relegation zone when Gracia was dismissed, making the decision a controversial one.


René Meulensteen – Fulham

René Meulensteen – Fulham

Photo: Getty Images


13 Premier League matches | 3 wins, 1 draw, 9 defeats

Meulensteen was promoted to Fulham manager in December 2013 after initially joining the club as Martin Jol's assistant.

He had previously worked alongside Sir Alex Ferguson at Manchester United, but his first managerial experience in England's top flight was extremely difficult.

Fulham collected just 10 points from 13 league matches under him. With the club struggling near the bottom of the table, Fulham decided to appoint Felix Magath in February 2014.

Meulensteen briefly returned to a coaching role before leaving the club entirely. Fulham were eventually relegated at the end of the season.


Jan Siewert – Huddersfield Town

Jan Siewert – Huddersfield Town

Photo: Getty Images


15 Premier League matches | 1 win, 2 draws, 12 defeats

Siewert inherited an almost impossible situation at Huddersfield in January 2019.

The German arrived with the club bottom of the table and already looking destined for relegation.

His only Premier League victory came against Wolves, with Huddersfield collecting just five points from his 15 matches.

The Terriers were relegated with several matches remaining, and Siewert was dismissed at the end of the season.

While the results were poor, he inherited a team that had been struggling for most of the campaign.


THE NEWEST ADDITION: PIERRE SAGE – CRYSTAL PALACE

pierre sage

Photo: Getty Images


16 matches in all competitions, 10 in the Premier League | 2 Premier League wins, 1 draw, 7 defeats

Sage's departure is particularly interesting because of the circumstances surrounding his appointment.

He arrived at Palace after Oliver Glasner had delivered the club's 2025-26 Conference League title.

Replacing a manager who had achieved so much was always going to be a difficult assignment.

Palace also had to balance domestic football with European commitments while losing some important players.

Nevertheless, the league performances were simply not good enough.

Two wins from 10 Premier League matches, seven points collected and four consecutive defeats left Palace bottom of the table.

The 3-1 home defeat to Liverpool proved decisive. Sage was dismissed on 12 November, just five months after signing a three-year contract.

It is another example of a club choosing immediate results over the longer-term project it initially promised.


MICHAEL CARRICK: ANOTHER MANAGER FALLS AT OLD TRAFFORD

carrick

Photo: Getty Images


Carrick's departure from Manchester United on the same day as Sage's makes this an especially remarkable week for Premier League managers.

However, his situation was very different. Carrick initially took charge as interim manager in January 2026 following Ruben Amorim's departure.

He made an immediate impact, guiding United to 11 wins in his first 16 matches and securing a third-place Premier League finish and Champions League qualification.

That form earned him a permanent contract in May. Unfortunately, the new season brought a dramatic change in fortunes.

United managed just three victories in their opening 15 matches across all competitions, with their league form leaving them in the relegation zone. A 4-4 draw against Aston Villa was the final match of his reign.

Carrick was dismissed on 12 November after approximately six months as the permanent appointment.

His overall spell was considerably longer than the managers featured in the list above, but his permanent-contract period lasted only 15 matches.

The contrast between his initial success and the club's subsequent collapse makes his departure one of the more interesting managerial stories of the season.


HOW MUCH TIME SHOULD A PREMIER LEAGUE MANAGER RECEIVE?


The cases of Sage and Carrick raise an important question about modern football.

Clubs increasingly talk about long-term projects, identity and stability, yet managers are still judged almost entirely on immediate results.

There are circumstances where a change is understandable. Relegation battles, dressing-room breakdowns and prolonged poor performances can force a club's hand.

But some of the examples above demonstrate just how little time managers are sometimes given.

Frank de Boer was dismissed after four league matches. Postecoglou lasted five. Les Reed was gone after seven.

Sage had 16 matches across all competitions, while Carrick was dismissed after 15 matches following his permanent appointment.

The Premier League remains one of the most competitive leagues in world football, but it is also one of the least forgiving environments for managers.

The question is no longer simply whether a manager can build a successful team. It is whether they will be given enough time to try.

Comments (0)

Sign in to comment, like or dislike.

Loading…

Explore Football Central